Causal closure of the physical, mental causation, and physicsAbstract
The argument from causal closure of the physical (CCP) is usually considered the most powerful argument in favor of the ontological doctrine of physicalism. Many authors, most notably Papineau, assume that CCP implies that physicalism is supported by physics. I demonstrate, however, that physical science has no bias in the ontological debate between proponents of physicalism and dualism. I show that the arguments offered for CCP are effective only against the accounts of mental causation based on the action of the mental forces of a Newtonian nature, i.e. those which manifest themselves by causing accelerations. However, it is conceivable and possible that mental causation is manifested through the redistribution of energy, momentum and other conserved quantities in the system, brought about by altering the state probability distribution within the living system and leading to anomalous correlations of neural processes. After arguing that a probabilistic, interactionist model of mental causation is conceivable, which renders the argument from causal closure of the physical ineffective, I point to some basic features that such a model must have in order to be intelligible. At the same time, I indicate the way that conclusive testing of CCP can be done within the theoretical framework of physics.
|
Towards a theory of emergence for the physical sciencesAbstract
I begin to develop a framework for emergence in the physical sciences. Namely, I propose to explicate ontological emergence in terms of the notion of ‘novel reference’, and of an account of interpretation as a map from theory to world. I then construe ontological emergence as the “failure of the interpretation to mesh” with an appropriate linkage map between theories. Ontological emergence can obtain between theories that have the same extension but different intensions, and between theories that have both different extensions and intensions. I illustrate the framework in three examples: the emergence of spontaneous magnetisation in a ferromagnet, the emergence of masslessness, and the emergence of space, in specific models of physics. The account explains why ontological emergence is independent of reduction: namely, because emergence is primarily concerned with adequate interpretation, while the sense of reduction that is relevant here is concerned with inter-theoretic relations between uninterpreted theories.
|
The role of the environment in computational explanationsAbstract
The mechanistic view of computation contends that computational explanations are mechanistic explanations. Mechanists, however, disagree about the precise role that the environment – or the so-called “contextual level” – plays for computational (mechanistic) explanations. We advance here two claims: (i) Contextual factors essentially determine the computational identity of a computing system (computational externalism); this means that specifying the “intrinsic” mechanism is not sufficient to fix the computational identity of the system. (ii) It is not necessary to specify the causal-mechanistic interaction between the system and its context in order to offer a complete and adequate computational explanation. While the first claim has been discussed before, the second has been practically ignored. After supporting these claims, we discuss the implications of our contextualist view for the mechanistic view of computational explanation. Our aim is to show that some versions of the mechanistic view are consistent with the contextualist view, whilst others are not.
|
Universality caused: the case of renormalization group explanationAbstract
Recently, many have argued that there are certain kinds of abstract mathematical explanations that are noncausal. In particular, the irrelevancy approach suggests that abstracting away irrelevant causal details can leave us with a noncausal explanation. In this paper, I argue that the common example of Renormalization Group (RG) explanations of universality used to motivate the irrelevancy approach deserves more critical attention. I argue that the reasons given by those who hold up RG as noncausal do not stand up to critical scrutiny. As a result, the irrelevancy approach and the line between casual and noncausal explanation deserves more scrutiny.
|
Action at a temporal distance in the best systems accountAbstract
Drawing on Earman’s (1986) definition of determinism and Lewis’ (Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 61, 343–377, 1983) best systems account of laws, in What Makes Time Special? (2017) Craig Callender develops an account of time as ‘the strongest thing’. The characterisation of this account apparently assumes no action at a temporal distance, an assumption that also underlies Earman’s account of determinism. In this paper I show that there is a way to define determinism that allows worlds with action at a temporal distance to count as deterministic, that action at a temporal distance is possible on a best systems account of laws, and hence that Callender need not make this assumption.
|
Complexity and integration. A philosophical analysis of how cancer complexity can be faced in the era of precision medicineAbstract
Complexity and integration are longstanding widely debated issues in philosophy of science and recent contributions have largely focused on biology and biomedicine. This paper specifically considers some methodological novelties in cancer research, motivated by various features of tumours as complex diseases, and shows how they encourage some rethinking of philosophical discourses on those topics. In particular, we discuss the integrative-cluster approach, and analyse its potential in the epistemology of cancer. We suggest that, far from being the solution to tame cancer complexity, this approach offers a philosophically interesting new manner of considering integration, and show how it can help addressing the apparent contrast between a pluralistic and a unitary account.
|
The principle of virtual work, counterfactuals, and the avoidance of physicsAbstract
Wilson (2017) derives various broad philosophical morals from the scientific role played by the Principle of Virtual Work (PVW). He argues roughly (i) that PVW conditionals cannot be understood in terms of things as large as possible worlds; (ii) that PVW conditionals are peculiar and so cannot be accommodated by general accounts of counterfactuals, thereby reflecting the piecemeal character of scientific practice and standing at odds with the one-size-fits-all approach of “analytic metaphysicians”; and (iii) that PVW counterfactuals are not made true partly by natural laws. I distinguish, elaborate and critically examine various arguments for these morals suggested by the PVW and Wilson’s text, looking especially at what makes a displacement “virtual” and the operation of the conditionals that the PVW takes to express necessary and sufficient conditions for equilibrium. Ultimately, I do not find the PVW to be especially well suited to support Wilson’s morals; some of these arguments fail, whereas others arise from general considerations rather than having to appeal to anything like the PVW.
|
Farmers’ experiments and scientific methodologyAbstract
Farmers all over the world perform experiments, and have done so since long before modern experimental science and its recognized forerunners. There is a rich anthropological literature on these experiments, but the philosophical issues that they give rise to have not received much attention. Based on the anthropological literature, this study investigates methodological and philosophical issues pertaining to farmers’ experiments, including the choice of interventions (work methods etc.) to be tested, the planning of experiments, and the use of control fields and other means to deal with confounding factors. Farmers’ experiments have some advantages over the field trials of agricultural scientists (more replications, studies performed under the relevant local conditions), but also some comparative disadvantages (less stringent controls, less precise evaluations). The two experimental traditions are complementary, and neither of them can replace the other. Several aspects of farmers’ experiments are shown to have a direct bearing on central topics in the philosophy of science.
|
“It might be this, it should be that…” uncertainty and doubt in day-to-day research practiceAbstract
This paper examines how scientists conceptualize their research methodologies. Do scientists raise concerns about vague criteria and genuine uncertainties in experimental practice? If so, what sorts of issues do they identify as problematic? Do scientists acknowledge the presence of value judgments in scientific research, and do they reflect on the relation between epistemic and non-epistemic criteria for decisionmaking? We present findings from an analysis of qualitative interviews with 63 scientific researchers who talk about their views on good research practice. We argue that analysts of science should care about scientists’ conceptualizations of the criteria and of the practical judgments that scientific inquiry involves. While scientists’ accounts of their own research methodologies alone do not give us a full picture of how science really works, they can point us to areas of concern. They can inspire and direct philosophical reflections about how science works. Throughout the interviews, the participating researchers provided specific examples from their own research contexts as illustrations of their methodological points. These examples reveal that scientists often struggle to evaluate the quality of their data, to figure out whether the available evidence confirms their hypothesis, whether a replication was successful, or to what extent they can rely on peer-reviewed papers. General ideas about good research methods do not directly translate into specific evaluation criteria or strategies that can guide research and help validate empirical data.
|
From physics to biology: physicists in the search for systemic biological explanationsAbstract
This paper offers a contribution to debates around integrative aspects of systems biology and engages with issues related to the circumstances under which physicists look at biological problems. We use oral history as one of the methodological tools to gather the empirical material, conducting interviews with physicists working in systems biology. The interviews were conducted at several institutions in Brazil, Germany, Israel and the U.S. Biological research has been increasingly dependent on computational methods, high-throughput technologies, and multidisciplinary skills. Quantitative scientists are joining biological departments and collaborations between physicists and biologists are particularly vigorous. This state of affairs raises a number of questions, such as: What are the circumstances under which physicists approach biological problems in systems biology? What kind of interdisciplinary challenges must be tackled? The paper suggests that, concerning physicists’ move to work on biological systems, there are common reasons to move, the transition must be understood in terms of degrees, physicists have a rationale for simplifying systems, and distinct conceptions of model and modeling strategies are recurrent. We identified problems regarding linguistic clarity and integration of epistemological aims. We conclude that cultural unconformities within the systems biology community have important consequences to the flow of scientific knowledge.
|
ΩτοΡινοΛαρυγγολόγος Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5 Agios Nikolaos 72100 Crete Greece,00302841026182,00306932607174,
Translate
Ετικέτες
Τετάρτη 13 Νοεμβρίου 2019
Αναρτήθηκε από
Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5 Agios Nikolaos 72100 Crete Greece,00302841026182,00306932607174,alsfakia@gmail.com,
στις
10:02 μ.μ.
Ετικέτες
00302841026182,
00306932607174,
alsfakia@gmail.com,
Anapafseos 5 Agios Nikolaos 72100 Crete Greece,
Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,
Telephone consultation 11855 int 1193
Εγγραφή σε:
Σχόλια ανάρτησης (Atom)
Αρχειοθήκη ιστολογίου
-
►
2023
(278)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (139)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (139)
-
►
2022
(1962)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (107)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (158)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (165)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (163)
-
►
2021
(3614)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (152)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (271)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (64)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (357)
-
►
2020
(3279)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (396)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (157)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (382)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (84)
-
▼
2019
(11718)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (265)
-
▼
Νοεμβρίου
(430)
- Ξηρή Μύτη
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Mechanistic insight of cyclin-dependent kinase 5...
- Developing Your Career as a Nurse Educator: Try ...
- Renal damage in primary aldosteronism: a system...
- The role of cannabis in treating anxiety: an up...
- Editorial: Body composition measurements in old...
- Editorial: Surgical advancements and innovation...
- Papillary thyroid microcarcinoma: optimal manag...
- Measuring outcomes in complicated intra-abdomin...
- Is the Use of Intraoperative Corticosteroids Har...
- Is the Use of Intraoperative Corticosteroids Har...
- Genetic and epigenetic factors interacting with...
- Novel therapeutic approaches in chronic kidney d...
- Introduction, vasculitis 2020, A monogenic auto...
- Asthma: a modifiable disease on a crossroadNo ab...
- Functional outcomes after selective dorsal rhizo...
- Stabilizing the Metzler matrices with applicatio...
- Edentulous left maxillary ridge ulcerative swell...
- Microbe-mediated sustainable bio-recovery of gol...
- Extradition and Mental Health in UK Law Abstrac...
- The bacteria-positive proportion in the disc tis...
- Surface deformation processes in the Carmel Faul...
- Epistemology and the History of Science: The Pro...
- Watch out! Insecure relationships affect vigilan...
- Combination Treatment with an Antibody–Drug Con...
- Clean technologies and policies for sustainable ...
- Central aortic blood pressure estimation in chil...
- Analysis of morphometric and somatoscopic traits...
- Lung and diaphragm-protective ventilation: setti...
- Ultrasonography greatly improves the ability of ...
- Regulation of allergic inflammation by dendritic...
- Effect of Low-Level LASER Therapy on Wound Recove...
- Augmented reality technology could be an alterna...
- Evaluation of the potential risk of benign parox...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- We thank You, God, for the food we eat; We thank y...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Biological Sciences, ,
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Sympathetic Nerve Traffic and Arterial Baror...
- 1. Epilepsy Behav. 2019 Nov 22;102:106681. do...
- Pharmaceutics, Vol. 11, Pages 630: Embedde...
- International Journal of Molecular Sciences,
- Antioxidants, Vol. 8, Pages 588: Modulatio...
- Profiling Ubiquitin and Ubiquitin-like Depen...
- Pediatric polysomnography-A review of indica...
- Poor Correlation of Oral Swabs with Esophage...
- An Invited Commentary on "Laparoscopic repai...
- Aberrant activation of cyclin A-CDK induces ...
- Olfactory dysfunction in patients undergoing...
- Cytological diagnosis of amyloidosis present...
- Symptomatic Post-Radiosurgery Intratumoral H...
- Awareness and practice of breast self examinatio...
- Gadolinium Retention as a Safety Signal: Experie...
- Free-living Evaluation of Laboratory-based Activ...
- Indian Journal of Nuclear Medicine 2019 34(5):1-2...
- Docosahexaenoic acid varies in rat skeletal musc...
- Clinical outcomes of new algorithm for diagnosis...
- A system approach on safe emergency evacuation i...
- Progressive histomorphometric analysis of the l...
- Editorial for Nigerian Journal of Health Science...
- Impact of Clinical Specialty Setting and Geogra...
- UCD School of Medicine, Summer Student Research ...
- State of the globe: Antimicrobial resistance: Ne...
- Αnesthesiology, emergency medicine and in...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- We'd never know how high we are, till we are calle...
- He whose honor is rooted in popular approval must,...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Tumors of the conjunctiva and cornea,Carol L Shi...
- Future of 5-fluorouracil in cancer therapeutics,...
- Size, site, and signaling: Three attributes of e...
- Role of nanotechnology in dentistry: Systematic ...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- Special Report, Coronary CT Angio...
- Ψευδάργυρος και ανοσογήρανση
- Immunotherapy and its advances in the management...
- Role of Ayurveda in end-of-life careMandip Goyal...
- Medicine by Alexandros G. Sfakianakis,Anapafseos 5...
- PeerJ Computer Science
- Many continuous variables should be analyzed...
- Manganese catalyzed ß‐methylation of alcohol...
- Latest Results for Review of Philosophy and P...
- Sialolipoma of Parotid Gland a Rare Histolog...
- Application of External Force Regulates the ...
- A Preprocess Method of External Disturbance S...
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (545)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (1143)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (744)
-
►
2017
(2)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (1)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (1)
Δεν υπάρχουν σχόλια:
Δημοσίευση σχολίου